Lion’s mane ɗaya ne daga cikin “kwayoyin ƙwaƙwalwa” da ake yawan talla a kasuwar ƙwayoyin abinci. Me ke faruwa idan manya masu lafiya sukan sha gram 2 a kowace rana na wata guda, sannan masana kimiyya su auna aikin mayar da hankali da matakin BDNF a jini?
Binciken ƙananan gwaji da aka wallafa a Nutrients ya yi ƙoƙarin amsa wannan tambaya. Gajeriyar sakamakon: babu wani bambanci da ya kai matsayin ƙididdiga. Bayanin cikinsa na da ban sha'awa fiye da talla ko watsi.
Menene masu binciken suka yi?
Ƙungiyar, mafi yawansu daga Jami'ar Nova Southeastern tare da alaƙa da kamfanin Substantiation Sciences, ta zaɓi mutane 10 masu lafiya, shekaru 18‑55. Kowane mahalarta ya sha gram 2 a kowace rana na ƙwayar Hericium erinaceus (lion’s mane) wadda aka tantance a matsayin na halitta, na tsawon kwanaki 28. Samfurin ya haɗa mycelial biomass da fruiting body.
Kafin da bayan makonni huɗu, mahalarta sun cika gwaje‑gwajen NIH Toolbox guda biyu na aikin gudanarwa:
- Flanker Inhibitory Control and Attention Test – yana auna yadda kake iya watsi da abubuwan da ba su da amfani kuma ka ci gaba da aikin.
- Dimensional Change Card Sort (DCCS) – yana auna sassauƙan tunani, wato yadda kake canza ka’idoji.
An auna plasma BDNF ta hanyar ELISA. Masu binciken sun kwatanta sakamakon kafin da bayan shan ƙwayar ta amfani da gwajin t‑test mai hade, sannan suka ƙididdige girman tasiri ta Cohen’s d.
Sakamako: babu canje‑canje masu ma’ana, ƙananan tasiri
Babban sakamakon ya bayyana: babu bambanci mai ma’ana na ƙididdiga (p > 0.05) a aikin gudanarwa ko plasma BDNF bayan kwanaki 28.
Girman tasiri ya kasance ƙanana‑zuwa‑matsakaici:
| Ma’auni | Cohen’s d |
|---|---|
| Flanker (inhibitory control/attention) | 0.48 |
| DCCS (cognitive flexibility) | 0.25 |
| Plasma BDNF | 0.31 |
Mawallafa sun bayyana waɗannan a matsayin “ɗan ƙaramin ci gaba daga matakin farko” da “alamar da ke da fata”. Sun kuma ƙara da cewa lion’s mane yana da aminci kuma an jure da shi a wannan ƙungiyar.
Menene wannan sakamakon ke nufi?
Ƙarancin mahalarta. Tare da mutane 10 ne, binciken ya rasa ƙarfin gano tasirin da ba su da girma. Rashin bambanci mai ma’ana ba yana nufin lion’s mane ba ya yi wani abu ba; yana nufin binciken bai sami ƙarfi don nuna wani tasiri ba. Girman tasiri daga ƙananan ƙungiya ba shi da tabbas, kuma zai iya sauyawa sosai idan an ƙara yawan mahalarta.
Babu rukunin placebo. An yi gwajin a buɗe, don haka kowa ya san abin da yake sha. Wannan yana ba da dama ga wasu abubuwa da ba su da alaƙa da ƙwayar su haifar da ƙananan tasiri:
- Tasirin maimaitawa: mutane kan samu sakamako mafi kyau a gwajin tunani na biyu.
- Tasirin tsammani: waɗanda suka yi imanin ƙwayar za ta ƙara musu ƙwaƙwalwa na iya ƙoƙari ƙara.
- Canjin yanayi na yau da kullum – bacci, damuwa, abinci da sauransu.
Sakamakon flanker (d = 0.48) shine mafi girma, amma wannan darajar na iya tasiri ne da tasirin maimaitawa.
BDNF alama ce mai wahala. Ana auna plasma BDNF da sauƙi, amma matakin sa na canzawa da lokaci, motsa jiki, damuwa, da yadda ake ɗaukar samfur. Canjin a jini ba lallai ya nufin canjin a kwakwalwa ba. d = 0.31 da bai kai ma’ana ba, a mafi kyawun hali, alama ce da ke buƙatar ƙarin bincike mai tsauri.
Alaƙar masana’antu, an bayyana
Bayanin rikicin sha’awa ya nuna cewa marubuta uku sun yi aiki a Substantiation Sciences a lokacin binciken. Babban marubuci, Jose Antonio, shi ne CEO kuma ɗaya daga cikin masu kafa International Society of Sports Nutrition – ƙungiya maras riba da ke karɓar tallafi daga kamfanonin ƙwayoyi, kuma yana ba da shawara ga wasu alamu. Wannan bayani yana nuna alamar yuwuwar son kai, duk da cewa ba ya rage ƙimar sakamakon gaba ɗaya.
Abubuwan da za a iya amfani da su a aikace
Matsakaicin da aka gwada. Binciken ya yi amfani da gram 2 a kowace rana na haɗin mycelium da fruiting body tsawon kwanaki 28. Wannan shi ne kawai adadi da sifar da binciken ke tallafawa. Ba a ba mu wata faɗaɗɗa game da manyan adadi, dogon amfani, ko wasu tsarin ba.
Fruiting body vs. mycelium. Wannan shi ne babban batun zaɓin samfur:
- Fruiting body shi ne ainihin ƙwayar. Samfuran da aka yi da shi yawanci suna bayyana hakan a fili, kuma sukan ƙunshi sinadarai da ake danganta da fa’idar ƙwaƙwalwa.
- Mycelium shine ƙwayar tushen da aka girma a kan hatsi. Saboda haka samfurin “mycelium” na iya ƙunsar ragowar substrate, wato abin da ka siya na iya bambanta da abin da aka yi amfani da shi a bincike.
- Saboda sinadarai masu tasiri na iya bambanta tsakanin ɓangarorin biyu, yana da muhimmanci ka nemi samfuran da ke bayyana wane ɓangare aka yi amfani da shi, adadin da ke kowane hidima, da kuma idan akwai gwaji na ɓangare na uku. “Proprietary blend” ba tare da bayani ba yana sanya wahala a kwatanta samfurin ka da abin da aka bincika.
Idan kana son bin wannan binciken, haɗin duka ɓangarorin a kusan gram 2 a kowace rana shine mafi kusa, amma shaidu ba su nuna cewa haɗin yafi ɗaya a kansa.
Tsammani na ainihi. Lion’s mane ba maganin “limitless” ko “kashi‑kashi” ba ne. Idan ƙananan alamu na wannan gwaji suna da gaskiya, za su kasance marasa ƙarfi kuma watakila ba za a gane su a kowanne yini ba. Kada ka dogara da sakamako daga kwalba kawai; ka fi mayar da hankali ga bacci, motsa jiki, da sarrafa damuwa.
Wanene zai iya gwadawa. Manya masu lafiya da ke da sha’awar wani abu mai ƙananan haɗari na iya la’akari da shi. Idan ka yanke shawarar gwadawa:
- Ka canza abu ɗaya a lokaci, don ka iya tantance ko wani abu ya bambanta.
- Ka bi diddigin aikin tunani da ka maimaita (misali, rikodin sakamakon Flanker ko DCCS), maimakon dogaro da “ji”.
- Ka ba shi makonni huɗu kamar yadda binciken ya yi, sannan ka sake duba sakamakon.
Ka tuntuɓi likita idan kana da ciki ko shayarwa, kana shan magani, kana da cutar ƙoda, ko kana son amfani da shi don magance matsalar ƙwaƙwalwa da aka tabbatar. Wannan binciken ya yi rajista da manya masu lafiya kawai, kuma ba zai iya magana kan waɗannan yanayi ba.
Kammalawa
Mawallafa sun kira sakamakon “alamar da ke da fata” kuma sun jaddada buƙatar manyan gwaje‑gwaje na dogon lokaci, da aka raba bazuwar, double‑blind, kuma mai ƙunshi placebo. Wannan shi ne tsari mafi inganci. A halin yanzu, gram 2 a kowace rana na lion’s mane na makonni 4 ya bayyana a matsayin aminci a cikin manya 10 masu lafiya, kuma ya haifar da ƙananan canje‑canje marasa ma’ana a hankali, sassauci, da BDNF. Ko lion’s mane yana ƙara mayar da hankali ko yana haɓaka BDNF a hanya mai ma’ana har yanzu tambaya ce har sai wani bincike mai ƙarfi ya amsa ta.